Pittsburgh, PA
Written by: Alexander F.
Some people claim suburban dining can’t rival the city for innovative and exciting restaurants. I disagree. After moving into the suburbs last summer, my wife and I traded late-night city spots for chain restaurants and mall options. At first we kept making the trek into Pittsburgh for the better meals, but a few stressful drives along West Liberty Avenue convinced us to look closer to home.
Over time I discovered that the South Hills suburbs have their own culinary highlights — some unexpected gems that consistently deliver great food and atmosphere. Below are my top suburban picks around Pittsburgh, each worth a stop whether you live nearby or are passing through.
Best Soup – Sherry Crab Bisque at Atria’s Mount Lebanon
The sherry in this creamy crab bisque adds a subtle, almost smoky sweetness that lifts it from a simple starter to the real attraction. The crab flavor is rich and satisfying, making this bowl a memorable way to begin a meal.
Best Pizza – Pepperoni’s in Bethel Park
Pepperoni’s is a favorite in our house. The pies are consistently good, the staff is friendly, and the casual BYOB vibe makes it an ideal spot for a relaxed Friday night in comfortable clothes. Great pizza without fuss.
Best Milkshake – Sarris Candies & Ice Cream Parlour in Canonsburg
Sarris is an institution in Washington County for a reason. Their chocolate confections are rich and silky, and their milkshakes are impressively large and delicious. If you appreciate a thick, generous shake, this place won’t disappoint.
Best Place for a Date – Il Pizzaiolo in Mount Lebanon
The upstairs wine bar at Il Pizzaiolo strikes an excellent balance between stylish and cozy. It’s not the cheapest option, but the atmosphere and quality make it a worthwhile choice for a special evening. If you’re aiming to impress, this spot delivers.
Best Brunch – Sugar Café in Dormont
Sugar Café on Potomac Avenue built a reputation for inventive menu items, quality coffee, and a lively atmosphere that appealed to many local diners. Although the café closed recently, its creative approach and delicious food left a strong impression. I’m including it here as an acknowledgement of what it contributed to the neighborhood and in the hope it might return.
Final note
The suburbs around Pittsburgh offer more than strip malls and chains — there are pockets of excellent food and welcoming places that rival the city’s options. Explore these picks next time you’re in the South Hills; you might be pleasantly surprised by what you find.
Author, Alexander F.
Catch Alexander on twitter: @alexanderfiv